Skip to main content

Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine - Reviews Without Spoilers

Reviews Without Spoilers is a series in which I review the books I've read without giving away any more than the inside cover plot summary would.



It seemed like practically everyone was reading Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine by Gail Honeyman. For some reason, perhaps the overwhelming popularity of the book or the silly-sounding title, I'd assumed this was a light, maybe even humorous novel.

While there are certainly laugh-out-loud funny parts, my assumptions of this book were most definitely wrong. I'd gone in totally blind, not even reading a single synopsis before I started it. All I knew was that it was part of Reese's Book Club...which was likely another reason I thought it'd be a light story, considering the Hallmark-y-ness of the last Reese book I read, One Day in December (you can see my review on that book here). I didn't even have the more-telling white version of the book's cover to go off of.

So, if you'd like to be a bit more in the know than I was, let's start with this...
CONTENT WARNING: physical and emotional abuse, sexual assault, self harm, alcoholism.

It doesn't sound so light and cheery anymore, does it?

This is a serious book. It's still a good book, but it's not one you should pick up if you're simply looking for a giggly beach read.

So, now that we've gotten that out of the way, let's get down to business. While I was initially thrown off by this story, I grew to love Eleanor and the people around her. Honeyman does an incredible job of making each person in this story feel human, from Eleanor's first friend to the owner of the store down the street. Everyone she encounters has a real personality, whether they take a starring role in the story or not.

Speaking of the people Eleanor meets, I listened to this book on Audible, which was both a blessing and a curse. I'm not sure what the print version looks like, but those Scottish accents can be quite a struggle to understand if you're not ready for it. Eleanor herself, who narrates the novel, is originally from England, and her narration was easy to understand. Whenever Eleanor encounters a true Scot, though, the voice actor does an incredible job of making it (somewhat realistically) near impossible to understand the first few times you hear it. Don't worry, though: the main characters have much more manageable accents.

This book is about a woman learning how to live. Her journey, despite its abundant difficulties, brings a message of hope. One of my absolute favorite scenes (don't worry, no spoilers) is when she starts to notice the details of the world around her. Reading through her discovery of the simple joys in life had me doing the same: I was newly mesmerized by the way the light hit the snow or the steam billowed from my teacup.

Further, Eleanor's process of discovery, her struggles and her successes, were realistic. She sought help from the right avenues, which could encourage readers with similar struggles to feel reassured by Eleanor's experience. However, I will also say that I found her healing process a bit too quick to believe. Granted, that's probably for the sake of narrative flow, but still.

All things considered, Eleanor gave me hope for the world. And, for that, I'm giving her 5/5 stars.

Book: Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine
Author: Gail Honeyman
Publisher: Pamela Dorman Books
Release Date: 2017
Genre: general fiction
Length: 336 pages, 11 hrs 2 mins in audiobook format
Setting: modern day Scotland

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Self Love, Part 1: A Beginning

"I hate going to the gym and seeing those overweight people wearing leggings and workout tops. If you need to wear anything bigger than a large, you should just stick to baggy t-shirts and sweatpants." An old coworker said this loudly while standing directly behind me. And I wear XL. I interacted with this person on a daily basis, and I assume the best in her. She didn't direct this statement toward me, and I'll give her the benefit of the doubt by assuming she didn't notice I was sitting right in front of her. I don't begrudge her for saying it, nor do I think the statement makes her mean or stupid or anything like that. But that doesn't negate the fact that I had to leave to go cry in the bathroom when I heard it. I didn't confront her or say anything to anyone about her statement. Maybe that's why it hurt so much. Obesity is a taboo subject for most people. We avoid talking about it because we don't want to make other people fee

Rediscovering Myself on Whole30

Before we go any further...What is Whole30? Essentially, it's an elimination diet that only allows you to eat "real" food: fruit, veggies, meat, and a few other odds and ends. You can have things like salt and oil to cook with, which helps a lot, too. The point is that you're avoiding added sugar, carbs and dairy (and, yes, alcohol too), completely getting them out of your system.  It's called Whole30 because you eliminate all of those "fake foods" for 30 days, but it's really like Whole50 if you do it right. That's because after the first 30 days, you're supposed to gradually add back in the foods you've been avoiding. If you really want to see how your body reacts to sugar (does it make you tired? overly emotional?), dairy (are there digestive problems? does your skin change?), and carbs (do you feel bloated? are you more or less full through the day?), you have to add them back in one at a time. For instance, you add dairy back

The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas

The Case for Audiobooks  My husband “doesn’t read books.” I knew that long before we got married, yet I’m still regularly shocked that I, a former English teacher and lover of language, married a man who doesn’t read. It’s not that he can’t read – he reads his grad school textbooks cover to cover. But he never chooses to read. He finds no joy in the notion of snuggling up with a good book to get lost in the story. The only time I’ve ever seen him read fiction was when I asked him to read with me for my birthday last year. Even then, he never finished the book. All of this was true until I suggested that we listen to an audiobook together in November. We would be driving back and forth across state lines for Thanksgiving and Christmas celebrations all winter, so why not spend that extensive time in the car together with a book? My husband begrudgingly agreed, so I downloaded The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas. Even with all the multi-hour car rides, it still took a long time to